Why Air America Failed

The liberal attempt to counter Rush Limbaugh on the airwaves was too little, too late.

Illustration by Trevor Davis.


The national talk-radio network Air America was founded on a can’t-miss premise: progressive mass media didn’t yet exist but should.

The year was 2004. George W. Bush was president, and his administration of neocons had lied and bullied America into a monstrous war in Iraq. Meanwhile, right-wing media increasingly looked like a license to print money. Rupert Murdoch’s Fox News had zoomed past CNN in the ratings, and Rush Limbaugh sat on the throne of a nationwide conservative talk radio empire. After 9/11, MSNBC edged closer to Fox in its editorial slant by hiring outspoken conservatives like Tucker Carlson and Pat Buchanan.

There was no media equivalent for liberals. Save for a few exceptions like Michael Moore, dissenting voices in the Bush era didn’t have a microphone big enough for the masses to hear. “The radio airwaves at the time . . . were like 91 percent conservative talk and 9 percent progressive,” said former Air America host Lizz Winstead. “People were starving for any other side of the story.”

Sorry, but this article is available to subscribers only. Please log in or become a subscriber.